Grip, the news known for its conservative attitudes of culture-like-based and political correctness, have announced this week that the Irish police have accessed access to private messages and IP addresses associated with their X account.
Gript, which cited the news without a “liberal filter”, called the “unbearable” and “egren” attack on the privacy and freedom of the media.
Elon Musk X, who said that he successfully challenged the judicial order, a joint statement of Gript, which is widely enhanced by conservative, populist and ultimate right accounts on the Ireland platform.
Gript’s announcement came to the days after the Vice President of the US President JD, in the field of free speech, censorship and immigration in Europe in the center of attention with a bright speech that loaded transatlantic relations and energizes political right to continent and beyond.
What exactly happened?
On Tuesday, the Gript announced a statement that the police asked for access to its communications to X as part of investigations in violent protests that occurred in April in April Planned accommodation for asylum seekers.
Gript, which also published what was said, was a copy of the court order, published recordings of the Protest in Newtownmountkenedy, about 40 km (25 miles) south of Dublin, including the scenes of violent conflicts between the police and protesters.
Grip’s protest recordings, during which six people were arrested, which seems to be seen to show the police using the pepper spray against one of its journalists between other conflicts between the officials and public members.
Gript said that no opportunity for challenging Garda Siochan was given, the name of the Irish police police, through his application for access to his communications or the results of the Court.
The output said that it only found out that the police searched for access to its communications after notified X.
According to the Judicial Order, which was published, the judge found that there was a “reasonable basis” for believing the shots published by the exit to X contained evidence of criminal offenses.
In monitoring the video, the editor of the Gript John McGuirk said that the police had aimed in the fight against the drug and “terrorists” to “very fake pronunciation” that could have evidence “that could have somewhere” somewhere.
“In journalism, it is very important to defend your sources, to defend your readers and defend the rights of those who work for you, up and to the point in prison, which I am ready,” McGuirk said in his video statement.
McGuirk said the police eventually left the offer without accessing private messages of his exit and other data after X successfully challenged the trail in court.
Gript did not respond to a comment request from Al Jazeere.
What kind of Irish police did she say?
In the statement Al Jazeeri, Garda Siochan said that he did not comment on the comments of third parties or ongoing investigations, but they acknowledged the court order.
“In order to revenge the rights of potential victims of crime, including Gardai who were orally and physically attacked, Garda Siochana has a positive obligation to obtain all available evidence,” spokesperson.
Siochana Garda told Lee or not to issue a judicial order the issue of an independent judiciary and that he needs “protection of journalists’ rights to report freely and surely.”
Siochana Garda did not answer the question of whether she was looking for communication between other media organizations or journalists.
What is the connection with Vance’s claims about free speech in Europe?
Conservative and extremely right figures in and outside Ireland pointed out the case as an example of what was claimed by Vance that Europe has been withdrawn from their “fundamental values”, including free speech.
The Gript I sought to draw a relationship, and McGuirk saying that his entry with the authorities “Very well” in the topic of the American vice president.
“I think that was timely that he did exactly as the consequences of the questions he was saying he was returning home for us,” McGuirk said in his video statement.
Harry Browne, a teacher of journalism on the Dublin University, said that the case involving the Gript raises legitimate concerns, but examine attempts to connect it to the Vand’s criticism of Europe.
“It refers but not surprisingly to use this tool for” return “tools through the platform, and probably twitter (the former name for X) was not alone,” Brownes Al Jazeera said, referring to Al Jazeer, calling is on Al Jazeera, referring to Al Jazeera, referring to Al Jazeera, referring to Al Jazeer, referring to Al Jazeeru, referring to Al Jazeera, referring to Al Jazeer, referring to the application to the police to access private messages on XI suggesting other social media platforms may have been similarly targeted.
“It offers no relationship between the European Digital Censorship regime,” Brown said that, despite Vance’s complaints, speech constraints in Europe will have aimed at the political left side, such as pro-Palestinian and anti-war activists, but those on the right.
In his change at the Security Conference in Munich last Friday, Vance said Europe withdrew from his “latest latest value” and faced a greater threat “from China or Russia.
“I look at Brussels, where EU Commissioners warn citizens to plan social media during civil unrest when they have seen what they have been assessed, quoted,” Fatefil Condeal said, “Fatefil Condeal said “” said “fatphilic content”.
“Or in this country, where the police performed raids against citizens suspected of publication of anti-feminist online comments as part, quote,” the fight against Misogy on the Internet “.
Vance speech received a cool response in Europe, whose governments have traditionally taken a proactive role in breaking hate speech from the USA.
Unlike the United States, where the first change of the Constitution limits the legal limitations of expression, the European Union has a long criminal hate speech related to the characteristics such as race, color, religion and national origin.
Individual Member States also have their own anti-leap spoken laws.
According to the EU’s significant digital service, it has also managed the Code of Behavior for Platforms for Surprise of Horse Speeches on the Network, which includes the commitment to review at least two-thirds of the contents brought in their notice within 24 hours .
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz took a particular kibre on Vance’s suggestion In order for German main political parties to release the opposition to the end person alternatives for Germany (AFD) that enter the government.
“Therefore, we cannot reconcile the commitment” never more “with the support of AFD,” Scholz said, using a common slogan associated with the lessons of Nazi Germany and the Holocaust.
“That is why we would not accept external observers who act on behalf of this party, interfering with our democracy and our choices and affect the democratic formation of opinion. These are bad manners – especially among friends and allies.”
Although Vance has set aside a number of punishment countries, including Germany, Sweden and the UK, among other things, the British man, who violated the ‘safe approach’ outside the abortion.
Vance, however, precisely asked worried about free speech in Ireland.
As an American senator in 2023. years, Vance wrote an Irish ambassador in the United States to express concern that the account of hate speech would consider the Irish Parliament “Cools an important public hearing.”
The Irish government published last year that it would not go forward with plans in the middle of the criticism from some opposition parties and numerous other prominent numbers on American law, including Tech billionaires Musk and President Trump.
Fergal Quinn, a lecturer in Limerik, said that he did not believe that Vance has much credibility because Trump administration interested only for the protection of his agenda, his criticism contains “the grain” of the truth. ”
“Free speech compared to hate speech has always been a tricky balance for entering the right,” Quinn said Al Jazeera said.
“The law in this area is far from perfect and is required to be constant sophistication, but free-all-on-line X which is the result of musk disastrophic step in terms of misinformation and polarization in public sphere.”
What reaction was in Ireland?
While the shares of the Guard Siochane criticized in conservative circles, including the United States, the case received relatively little attention in Ireland.
Most Irish media – including RTE National Emiter and the leading newspaper Irish time and Irish independently – did not report as much as attracted significant attention to conservative and ends and media platforms.
The National Community of Journalists, who advocates for the freedom of the media in Ireland, did not publish a statement and refused to comment when contacted by Al Jazeera.
The muffled reaction in Ireland may be the consequence of the polarined nature of the Gript in the country in which the policy is based on the consensus of the norm and right-handed populists and the distant right groups have made several introductory countries in relation to other Western countries.
The grip covers the news through direct conservative lenses and is strongly critical to the scale of Irish asylum intake and its liberal positions on cultural issues such as abortion rights and transgender rights.
He deals with his website as an alternative to readers concerned about “heads in the most extreme forms of liberalism, facilitated by pushing any actual discussion.”
Before entering journalism, McGuirk was involved in numerous political parties with the central right and helped leading abortion and greater integration with the EU.
The output has been criticized over the accuracy of some coverage.
2023. He removed an article that was incorrectly connected by Algerian asylum seekers a stabbing attack on three children and teachers outside Dublin school.
The man, who was not appointed in the article, but was identified on social media through details about his asylum history, is currently suing the grip for defamation.
Study of the Institute for Strategic Dialogue, a research tank describing their mission as a combat, hatred and misinformation “, described as a” reputable entity in the Irish ecosystem “that had a record correct” fake and misconduct “on immigration.
Gript denied far-laws and last year, he successfully claimed the writ of the press that the article accused of being “racist” and “mixing hatred against immigrants”, did not meet the accuracy industry standards.
“Gript is an unpopular and problematic informative organization that several times skipped a line of hatred because it is requested – with limited success – to drive a wave of right-wing policies around the world,” said University of Limerick.
“I wouldn’t say it was wrong for every question that is pushing, but I’d say he’s not credible.”
Still, Quinn said it was “in principle” that the police go to the media surgery regardless of his credibility.
“There is history in Ireland Gardai, using their powers overly in these areas and wide concepts, with freedom of speech sometimes the principle that is roughly allowed, not rigorously supported,” he said.
Tom Felle, an associate professor of journalism at the University of Galway, expressed similar concerns.
“Freedom of the media is the basic column of any democracy, and the breach threshold for Freedom to be extremely high,” Felle said Al Jazeera said.
“Such actions should only occur in the rarest circumstances and when they are absolutely necessary in the public interest.”
https://www.aljazeera.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/GettyImages-2153053634-1740039429_0a0477-1740121570.jpg?resize=1200%2C630&quality=80
2025-02-21 22:13:00
